article thumbnail

Best Evidence Rule Requires Post-Level Collection for Social Media Evidence

Next Generation E-Discovery Law & Tech Blog

By John Patzakis The Best Evidence Rule, as codified in Federal Rule of Evidence 1002, provides that an original writing, recording, or photograph is required to prove the contents of the document. The plaintiff had deleted his Facebook account resulting in lost evidence critical to the case.

article thumbnail

California's Secondary Evidence Rule: Helpful, Yes. But Not an End Run.

Evidence at Trial

California's secondary evidence rule (Cal. Code §§ 1521 - 1523) provides a commonsense approach that begins with a simple general rule: "The content of a writing may be proved by otherwise admissible secondary evidence." Even simpler, the secondary evidence rule cannot be used as an end-run around the rules of evidence.

Insiders

Sign Up for our Newsletter

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

Trending Sources

article thumbnail

Employer Erred by Downloading Former Employee’s Personal Email; But, Failure to Preserve it Was Not Spoliation; and, There Was a Gap in Employee Handbook Clause Permitting Employer Access Post-Termination

E-Discovery LLC

But, the Court found and held that there was no evidence that the defendants had read the emails after plaintiff’s termination. The Court rejected invasion of privacy and wiretap claims because there was no evidence that the employer had read the emails after the plaintiff was terminated. Shapiro’s post-termination emails.”

Evidence 130
article thumbnail

The Federal “Official Information” Privilege

E-Discovery LLC

In order to assert it: “The objection must be accompanied by a declaration or affidavit ‘from a responsible official within the agency who has personal knowledge of the principal matters to be attested to in the affidavit or declaration.’” For more, see Mark S. 142 (1976); K. Graham, Federal Prac. & & Proc. 5676 (1 st ed).

article thumbnail

Multiplicity: I Got It — There’s a Lot of Them

Attorney at Work

An exception is for technical or precise words such as “affidavit.” If you assert that there are a whole bunch of things and your opponent shows evidence that there are many fewer, your entire case may be tarnished. Repeated use of long words like “multiplicity” comes across as pompous, not learned. Multiplicity” can be vague.

article thumbnail

Geofence Search Warrant Held Valid

E-Discovery LLC

The police affidavit stated: Based on that information, the affiant requested permission to search Google’s business records for “anonymized DeviceID data” of cell phone users that reported a location within a 100-meter radius of the main residence of the [victim’s] Frederick Road property between April 3 and April 11, 2020.

article thumbnail

Passing of Senate Bill 458 Helps Reform Civil Asset Forfeiture in Kansas

Joseph, Hollander & Craft

Substantial due process protections implemented by the bill include a requirement that commencement of forfeiture proceedings be supported by a probable cause affidavit, a requirement that clear and convincing evidence support a final forfeiture order, and a requirement that courts consider whether forfeiture is excessive under the circumstances.